Banks and non-banking financial institutions have spent years solving connectivity. But what if connectivity is no longer the real challenge? Drawing on new global research, Zhenya Winter, Head of Global Marketing – Financial Messaging at Bottomline and author of The Payments Intelligence Gap global report, argues that the next competitive divide in payments will be defined not by how many networks an institution can connect to, but by how intelligently it can use the data, controls and workflows between them.
For more than two decades, I’ve watched the definition of payments modernisation change. Network access, standardisation and faster payments have each been held up as markers of progress. They all mattered. But each solved one problem while exposing the next. I think we now need to challenge one of our own assumptions.
That doesn’t mean every connectivity challenge has disappeared, or that connectivity has become less important. It remains fundamental to the movement of money. But connectivity on its own is no longer a good way to measure payments modernisation.
A financial institution can be connected to Swift, domestic clearing systems and real-time payment schemes and still struggle to understand what is happening to a payment. It can implement ISO 20022 and still have poor-quality structured data. It can make payments faster while discovering errors too late. And it can deploy multiple fraud controls while lacking a joined-up view of risk across the payment lifecycle. Those aren't really connectivity problems. They're intelligence problems.
Our latest research, The Payments Intelligence Gap global report, draws on the views of more than 300 professionals from banks and non-banking financial institutions globally. What interested me wasn't any single statistic, but the same theme appearing across ISO 20022, fraud, resilience, cross-border payments, AI and operational efficiency: institutions have more technology, connections and data at their disposal than ever before, but turning those assets into better outcomes remains difficult.
And that makes knowing where you stand even more important.
Financial institutions can't judge their progress in isolation. They need to understand how they compare with their peers, where competitors may be moving faster and whether their priorities reflect what customers, regulators and the wider payments ecosystem will demand next.
This isn't benchmarking for benchmarking's sake. Are you keeping pace with customer expectations? Can you respond to regulatory and compliance change without another major technology project? Are your fraud controls keeping up as payments accelerate? Are you getting enough value from ISO 20022 and richer payments data? And can you introduce new capabilities quickly enough to be seen as an innovator rather than a follower?
That is why benchmarking is central to this year's research. The Payments Intelligence Gap report looks at where the market is moving and where a group we call the Payment Pioneers are pulling ahead of their peers. The live benchmarking survey then turns the question back on individual institutions: where do you sit? Some of the gaps are bigger than I expected.
ISO 20022 Proves the Point
I've been involved in the ISO 20022 conversation for many years, and much of the early discussion was understandably about migration. Could institutions send and receive the new messages? Were their systems ready? Now the conversation needs to move on.
In our research, 65% of respondents identified structured data quality as the biggest barrier to becoming ISO 20022 enabled. Yet the most sought-after use case for ISO 20022 over the next 12 to 24 months was higher straight-through processing, cited by 38%. More efficient investigations and fraud and sanctions screening followed.
For years we've talked about ISO 20022 giving financial institutions richer data. Now we need to ask a harder question: are we actually doing anything valuable with it? An incomplete address or missing piece of payment information detected after submission still creates an exception. Someone has to investigate it, repair it and potentially resubmit the payment. The customer may experience a delay. Operations absorbs the cost. Find the same problem before the payment enters the flow and the outcome changes completely.
The industry needs to shift from fixing problems after the event to spotting them before they happen. Modernisation shouldn't simply help us process payments faster. It should help us prevent avoidable problems in the first place.
Faster Isn't Necessarily Smarter
We have spent years pursuing faster payments, and speed has unquestionably created real benefits for customers and corporates. But faster isn't automatically smarter. A bad payment travelling faster is still a bad payment. In some circumstances, it's a bigger problem because there is less time to identify something unusual and intervene.
Fraud makes that particularly clear. 44% of respondents identified mid-transaction fraud detection as the biggest security gap in the payment lifecycle. Another 28% pointed to pre-payment validation, while 19% highlighted end-to-end visibility.
The collective picture is more interesting than any individual number. Fraud doesn't fit neatly into one stage of a transaction, so our defences can't either. Beneficiary verification, behavioural and transactional intelligence, sanctions screening, transaction monitoring and investigations need to work as connected controls before, during and after a payment. The faster money moves, the more important that intelligence becomes.
Do We Need Another Connection?
Each time a new scheme, network, regulation or capability emerges, the natural response is to connect to it. But at some point, more connectivity starts creating more complexity.
Financial institutions are already managing multiple payment rails, networks, providers and technology environments. Add instant payments, ISO 20022, changing regulatory requirements and emerging settlement models, and payments become increasingly difficult to manage as a collection of separate connections. So perhaps the question isn't: “What do we need to connect to next?” but “How do we make everything we're already connected to work better together?” That's where orchestration becomes interesting.
For me, orchestration is about bringing payment data, status information, fraud intelligence, validation, compliance controls and operational visibility together so institutions can see, understand and act across the payment lifecycle.
And this is where the research reveals a striking difference. 50% of Payment Pioneers reported good or excellent agility when integrating new payment solutions, compared with just 7% of other institutions. They also found it easier to collaborate with industry peers, third-party providers and regulators, at 42% versus 13%.
Their stronger outcomes aren't confined to integration. Our research shows Payment Pioneers performing better across areas including processing speed, compliance automation, fraud detection, operational efficiency and cash visibility. Innovation appears to have a multiplier effect when it connects problems traditionally treated in isolation.
Technology Should Reduce Complexity, Not Add to It
There's a challenge here for technology providers too. Financial institutions don't need another isolated solution to another isolated problem. They have enough complexity already.
At Bottomline, connectivity is part of our heritage. We're a Top 3 Swift service provider, managing 15% of international cross-border traffic and processing 10 million Swift messages each day.
What decades of working in payments has shown us is that complexity rarely disappears. It moves. Solve connectivity and the challenge moves into data, workflows, exceptions, fraud controls and interoperability. That's why our own direction is moving beyond connectivity alone. Global Pay Connect reflects that thinking, bringing connectivity together with data, fraud controls and interoperability across more of the payment workflow. But the broader point matters more than any one platform. Technology partners need to help financial institutions get greater value from the infrastructure they already have, while making it easier to adapt as networks, regulations and customer expectations change.
The true test of modernisation isn't reaching some imagined future state. It's being able to keep adapting without multiplying cost, risk and complexity every time the market changes.
AI Is Not the Strategy
AI inevitably enters this conversation, but payments needs to be pragmatic about it. Our research found that 48% of respondents consider AI integration a critical or high priority over the next 12 months. Yet none reported fully integrated, autonomous AI within their payment solutions.
I'm not convinced full autonomy should be the immediate goal. Some of the most valuable applications may sound less dramatic: improving payment data quality, spotting unusual activity, helping identify fraud, supporting reconciliation and giving people better information on which to make decisions.
Given that 65% of respondents identified structured data quality as their biggest barrier to becoming ISO 20022 enabled, applying intelligence to payment data could have an impact far beyond one process.
In a regulated industry, AI should help people make better decisions, not make it harder to understand how those decisions were reached. AI isn't the payments strategy in itself. Better intelligence is. It’s a tool that can help us make better use of the intelligence we have, while keeping people involved in the decisions.
Measuring Payments Modernisation
After looking across this research, I keep coming back to some deceptively simple questions:
- How much intelligence exists between your connections?
- Can you see a payment across its lifecycle?
- Can you identify poor data before it creates an exception?
- Can fraud controls work together rather than as isolated checkpoints?
- Can you adapt when the next major industry change arrives without having to start again?
For me, those questions tell us much more about the maturity of a payments operation than the number of networks it connects to. Connectivity got the industry a very long way. But connectivity isn't the competitive advantage anymore. What you know, understand and can do across those connections is. That's the Payments Intelligence Gap.
The financial institutions that close it won't necessarily be those with the most technology. They will be the ones that make their technology, data and expertise work together most intelligently.
Where Does Your Institution Sit?
Perhaps the question for 2027 isn't: “How connected are we?” It's: “How much value are we creating from those connections?” And that's difficult to answer by looking only at your own transformation programme. You need to know where your peers are investing, where Payment Pioneers are getting better results and where gaps are opening in your own strategy. The full Payments Intelligence Gap global report explores those questions across modernisation, connectivity, fraud prevention, operational resilience, ISO 20022 and AI.
Read The Payments Intelligence Gap to see where the industry is heading. Then take the live benchmarking survey to see how your institution compares and contribute to the next phase of the research. Because in a market moving this quickly, knowing where your competitors are going matters. Knowing where you stand matters even more.
Share