Skip to content

Alert Banner Text Goes Here Alert Banner Text Goes Here Alert Banner Text Goes Here Alert Banner Text Goes Here

Start Now

Exposure Management: Prioritizing Cyber Risk in the Age of AI

The Payments Podcast by Bottomline

Episode Transcript

Owen McDonald (host): Welcome to The Payments Podcast. I'm your host, Bottomline Managing Editor, Owen McDonald. Cybersecurity continues to be a difficult exercise in setting priorities. Organizations face a growing list of vulnerabilities and expanding digital footprint, and attackers who are using AI to find and exploit weaknesses faster than we've ever seen, but identifying every potential vulnerability isn't the same as understanding which ones pose the greatest threat.

That is the job of exposure management, promising a more intelligent way to judge cyber risk, focus security resources, and strengthen resilience. Joining me to explain why this matters and how it works are two of Bottomline's cybersecurity leaders, Chief Information Security Officer, Chirag Patel, and Senior Director of Security Operations, Blaine Brennecke. Chirag, Blaine, welcome to The Payments Podcast.

Chirag Patel (guest): Great to be here. Thanks for having us.

Blaine Brennecke (guest): Thanks for having us.

Owen McDonald: I am so glad you're both here. It's a fascinating topic. Let's begin with you, Blaine. What is exposure management, and how does it differ from traditional vulnerability management?

Blaine Brennecke: For a long time, the industry has looked at vulnerability management as this concept of bad things that we need to chase coming in and fixes we need to apply going out. But over the course of the past twelve to twenty-four months, we've seen a drastic shift with the alignment of AI technologies, and we'll talk about that in a moment, but where VM failed was that it was unable to address what really mattered. It treated vulnerabilities as a pile of theoretical problems in your environment, and you were forced to go through an exercise that evaluated what was material risk. When you're dealing with thousands of these vulnerabilities over the course of a year, you're spending countless hours after hours of trying to figure out what matters.

For a lot of teams, it just doesn't scale well. Exposure management flips that problem on its head. It looks at all of the things coming in, and it takes into account all of your various security controls, the posture of the network, the posture of the assets that are managed by Bottomline. And it says that this vulnerability applies to this asset. And because that asset is exposed to the outside world or maybe it's missing a control or maybe there's some sort of gap in the way that the configuration on that system has been deployed, it helps us process what is a material risk.

It helps us take that wide chasm of data that's coming into the business, that mountain of vulnerabilities, and say we're not going to focus on everything and treat it equitably, we're going to focus on the material risk. And exposure management helps us narrow down what that material risk is into an actionable pile of work rather than a mountain of theoretical and ephemeral vulnerabilities that don't move the needle for the posture of the business.

Owen McDonald: Understood. It's a great explanation. Chirag, why is exposure management becoming more important at the same time that AI is changing the scale and sophistication of cyberattacks? What's the connection?

Chirag Patel: Yeah Owen, AI has suddenly changed the economics on how cyberattacks have evolved. It's like Blaine mentioned earlier, it's a volume and a speed challenge.

In the last five years, the volume of new vulnerabilities has grown 36-fold. Let me repeat that one. 36-fold. At the same time, we have to respond to these with a much more compressed timeline. What used to take months for threat actors to figure out how to exploit a vulnerability, now takes days and sometimes only hours. If you keep up with the industry and what's happening out there with the research stuff, the Cloud Security Alliance reported that AI systems can now generate working proof of concept exploit code for published vulnerabilities and in as little as ten to fifteen minutes.

So, for us, we've got to keep up with that. So, I'd actually reframe that to saying exposure management is no longer important or just nice to have. It's fundamental for the success of any cyber organization, across the industries.

Owen McDonald: That sounds very important indeed. Following up on that, Blaine, tell us how exposure management is changing the way security teams decide which threats get urgent attention.

Blaine Brennecke: That was fantastic question. It ties back to the sentiment that Chirag was just stating in terms of volume. If we look at exposure management as a way of chasing that material risk, it's no longer just about finding a patch for something. We're not just patching systems to try to mitigate a threat. We're actually applying a series of controls.

We're bolstering our EDR solutions. We're bolstering our cloud controls. We're bolstering our network security solutions. So, exposure management is actually helping us refine the way that we address them by providing alternate mechanisms for mitigation, which is a huge benefit to the teams that otherwise used to rely on slow or out of cycle patching cadences. So, as it's helping us approach that area differently, when we look at critical threats that come in, we're actually able to come up with unique pathways for addressing those threats.

This is a very timely conversation because we're just coming off of the PHP to Shell exploit that occurred earlier this week. In a traditional model, we would have just been waiting for that patch to come out before we could do anything, which could be valuable hours lost, days lost, depending upon how long it takes for a patch to be released. Exposure management allows us to take those critical, novel vulnerabilities and look at them through a different lens of disabling a connection or enabling a secondary control. So, we're able to have a more precise and prescriptive approach to how we approach the threats rather than looking at it through the lens of being on our back heel waiting for a patch to come through.

It really does give us more control over our response, and it puts the business in the driver's seat. It's an unfortunate dynamic in the industry where patches don't come out often within days or sometimes weeks and that dynamic's changing. Now that we've got this type of exposure management lens to view these problems through, it really gives us a force multiplier to go and chase a risk reduction immediately rather than having to wait until a third party gives us a solution.

Owen McDonald: It's so important. You made a hugely important point there. Still, given that no business can eliminate every vulnerability, Chirag, how should business leaders determine where their security investments will deliver the greatest protection?

Chirag Patel: Yeah, it's a great point. I try to echo and communicate that to some of my leaders all the time in the business and technology side.

Here's one. I love numbers, by the way. You'll see that. Here's where numbers, really put things into perspective.

So, while the growth of vulnerabilities has been drastic and we're now in the tens of thousands of new vulnerabilities identified every year, last year, only about 1% of the published vulnerabilities were actually exploited. The trick for the companies is to find that 1% in their environment. That's where you get the biggest ROI, for that. So, if my capacity to fix something is limited, which, by the way, every company's capacity is always going to be limited of how fast they can fix things, they need a way to figure out how to chase that 1% as fast as they can and get the biggest ROI for that.

How I think about that and how Blaine and I really think about that when it comes to exposure management is, we've got to be able to answer two questions every day, all day, continuously. Are my existing security tools, are the areas where we are already spending millions of dollars, in the latest security stack, are they giving me any lift for protecting us against those vulnerabilities? And if they are, then great. Then I don't need to chase that immediately. I need to eventually get to that vulnerability, but I don't need to stop everything and go fix that vulnerability today.

The second question is the inverse of that. Which vulnerabilities have no protection whatsoever? I've spent millions of dollars in the layers of security, but we're getting nothing. Those are the ones we want to ask our technology partners to say, stop everything you're doing and go get this done, fixed today, for that.

Owen McDonald: The blaring emergency button on those, I get it. Blaine, I'm curious about what happens operationally when an organization adopts exposure management. What have you learned from developing Bottomline's own exposure management response?

Blaine Brennecke: I think the biggest shift is less to do with the technology and more to do with an order of thinking. Because we've been buried in this legacy, VM process for decades as an industry, volume in, volume out, it has created this habitual way of thinking that every time there's a vulnerability that shows up in the news or shows up on a dashboard, it requires something. And that's a very difficult thing to break away from.

I think the biggest thing that we've learned, as we continue to go through this journey, is that exposure management is just as much a technological shift as much as it is a philosophical, an operational, and even a strategic one in terms of how we're approaching investment. A lot of what we're doing today to try to move in a direction of exposure-oriented thinking is chasing those material risks that I mentioned earlier and getting away from dashboards and widgets being the primary drivers for what constitutes action.

It doesn't mean that we don't have those dashboards or those widgets, but they're changing. They're morphing to things that actually tell us something that we need to go and do. So, we're also giving our remediation teams on the product lines more levers to pull. You don't just have that patch. You've also got other controls you can go implement. Even that is a small but significant change in the way that we approach these problems because, again, a lot of folks are used to waiting on that patch.

I'll use the security alerts volume as a good illustration of why the problem has to be reinterpreted. In 2025, most organizations had somewhere in the ballpark of 500 to 600,000 security alerts per year. That's a significant volume and a lot of that is vulnerability data. In 2026, that number is already averaging up over 850,000. So, if we were to continue down this pathway, it leads to this circle of constantly staring at dashboards and trying to assess, are we going to look at everything? We'll never get there.

So, part of the challenge has been providing the right type of assurance to know that we're treating the right things and that there are some vulnerabilities that come across our boards, that because they aren't exposed, they're not reachable. We've got controls in place. We don't need to treat them with the same level of urgency. That doesn't mean they don't get treated. What it does mean is it buys us valuable time to go and focus on the critical matters.

That subtle shift in thinking takes a little bit of time because, again, we've got these ingrained habits. But I think what's been the biggest lesson is just the communication around how to think about the problem. The tools can do all the hard work for us. They can help us find the problems. It's how we think about what those problems are when they're presented to us.

Owen McDonald: And the prioritization obviously comes out of it. Right?

Blaine Brennecke: Precisely.

Owen McDonald: Yeah. From a C-Suite perspective, Chirag, what does it take to make the transition to exposure management successful?

Chirag Patel: There are a few things that come to mind, Owen, for that. I think first and foremost is that mindset shift across the board, not just the cyber, but cyber technology and business leaders. We need to move away from measuring how much security we do to focusing on how much risk we're reducing. I think that's fundamental, especially in the world of AI and the world of automation and the world of how things move so fast is quantity really, really matters over quality.

As the CISO, for me, what's really, really important is the right measures. What are the measures I'm taking to my risk committee, to my board? And are those the right measures? Because, ultimately, if they see a big red item, they expect action to be taken. So, am I getting the support in the right direction or not? So, starting with the right measures that are focused on risk reduction versus 'look at all the security stuff we need to do or are we doing', is fundamental to get that transition happening.

Then last but not least, automation and data driven. In in the world of AI and how things move, we have to shift from a point-in-time assessment to continuous assessment, and it has to be data driven. We can't afford a place where we go to the asset owner, and the asset owner claims that the asset is not exposed to the Internet. It needs to be data driven. It needs to come from an authoritative source to give me comfort that it's not exposed, and we need to move on to the next one in there too.

But I think those are three fundamental things, for that shift.

Owen McDonald: Last question. It always goes by so fast, but maybe you can both take a swing at this one. In an overall sense, what should CFOs, treasury leaders, and executives take away from this conversation we're having about managing cyber risk and strengthening resilience with exposure management? Let's hear from you first, Blaine.

Blaine Brennecke: I echo a lot of what Chirag just mentioned about the notion of having a data driven lens. But I think from a business perspective, if we just take this as a business problem, it needs to be solved. We can't get away from the fundamentals. The fundamentals aren't changing. It's the way that the fundamentals are presenting that is changing.

Risk assessments are still important. Crown jewel assessments are still important. You need to know what you have, where it resides, why it matters. When we're applying these new technologies and these new ways of thinking to how we address vulnerability management, exposure management, cyber risk, etcetera, those fundamentals haven't gone away.

But what we do need to do is keep up with the speed of attack, maintain good speed of defense, and that doesn't happen by maintaining the status quo. Unfortunately, most of the existing solutions to these problems that we've had in the past couple years are no longer adequate. And at the rise of AI, the Mythos problem, OpenAI's letter to the global CEOs earlier this year, there's enough data at this point that should spur action.

That action should be placed in strategic investment. It should be placed in education, not only for cyber practitioners and product owners, but also for the executives to understand that if we don't move quickly, we're going to quickly fall behind. And that problem to get ourselves out of that pile of mess that will be created in that dwell time will be a lot of work. So, the faster that we can get ahead of this problem by adopting strategic solutions and having those strong investments and good cyber controls and reinventing the way that we approach these problems to be more agile and more focused on the things that are really materially driven by exposure and the criticality of the risk that's tied to it, it will lead to more prudent action, and it will keep businesses safe.

Owen McDonald: Well said. Chirag, a closing thought from you on managing cyber risk with exposure management?

Chirag Patel: Yeah, for the business leaders and executives and tier fours, just like how we typically say, there's no such thing as a 100% secure system. Similarly, there's never going to be enough money you can throw at this problem. So, my thought on what business leaders and CFOs should think about is really challenge their security leaders to help educate them on how much risk is being reduced. What is the ROI?

We don't make money. We are cost centers. So, for us, the ROI is demonstrating how much risk we are reducing in the environment and for the business functions. What's the exposure we're reducing? What's the impact to their business and their asset and their processes if we don't manage that risk? Ultimately, are we operating within our risk tolerance level? That's where the focus and the conversations need to be between the business and the security leaders.

Owen McDonald: Well, there you have it. Exposure management represents an important change in how organizations approach cybersecurity. Rather than treating every vulnerability as an equal threat, it helps security teams understand where their greatest risks are, how those weaknesses might be exploited, and where to focus defenses. As the threat landscape grows more complex, that difference is crucial to protecting the business. A huge thanks to Chirag Patel and Blaine Brennecke for their insights.

To our audience, the smartest people in B2B payments, thanks for listening. Hit subscribe. Catch us again on your favorite podcast platforms, including Apple, Spotify, Blubrry, iHeartRadio, and YouTube. Bye for now. 

The Payments Podcast from Bottomline.